On this certain day, I was walking on 14th Street, passing the south end of the Square on my way from class to the gym. Walking along, I notice today is another one of the many, endless days where the miniature, elevated amphitheater is hosting a demonstration of some sort. Usually, the crowd is gathering for something political - the freeing of Tibet or the praising of Barack Obama or whatever. You get the idea.
Today, the meaning seems ambiguous since I don't see any signs and the gentleman with the megaphone is too far away for me to hear. I pause for a moment on the far side of the street and look over. There's another change of pace today as it seems everyone is seated on the hard cement instead of in their usual, upright and locked positions. Two or three people stand on the fringes of the seated mass and attempt to pass out printed literature to all passersby, no matter how disinterested they may look. Each one of these people is also armed with a clipboard, most likely for collecting money or information of some sort. My curiosity piquing, I decide to cross the street. I've got time to kill and the gym sure as hell isn't closing in the next twelve minutes.
I walk up to a middle-aged woman with her brown ponytail pulled through the back of a baseball cap. She sees me coming and instinctively thrusts one of her folded pieces of paper toward me. I take the leaflet from her well-manicured hand and look down as I begin to open it up. I also engage the enemy.
"So, what's this for?" I ask curiously.
"The paper?" she replies.
"Well, I assume the paper is for whatever is going on here, right?" I ask and motion my head toward the crowd. The man with the megaphone is close enough to hear at this point, but I'm not really paying attention to him. I look back down at the propaganda in my hand.
She laughs. "Yeah, sorry. Stupid question. It's just nobody ever actually comes up to talk to me, so I froze." She laughs again.
"Oh," I smile, "no problem. So what's it about then? Some kind of anti-war protest from the look of this page here."
"That's right," she begins and quickly falls into a well-rehearsed and pre-planned speech. "We're here today in demonstration against the Iraq War. Over four thousand of our US troops have been killed so far in battle and today we are urging the government to bring our troops home and begin a resolution of peace and not of war. Are you registered to vote?"
"I am, but not in New York, sorry," I reply and continue to frequently glance down at the paper in my hand. This way I can avoid eye contact but still seems as though I'm deeply interested in the matter.
"Awwww, too bad. We're collecting signatures for a petition to send to Congress which demands immediate action on their part to construct a formal plan of withdrawal in an immediate and timely manner. If you don't mind me asking, what are your feelings on the war?"
She's polite, but almost too polite; like a phone service operator. You can call these people and swear and curse at them and tell them you fucked their mother in the ass and they still call you sir or ma'am and use words like 'please' and 'thank you'. It makes me feel slightly uncomfortable. I continue nonetheless.
"My feelings on this war and nearly any and all armed conflicts can be summed up in the quote 'Make drinks, not war'. I find that a nice rum and coke can solve most issues of anger and tension among individuals."
She laughs a bit nervously, but nods her head and says, "Well, okay."
"But, no," I continue "I do agree that this war is a joke. I call it 'Vietnam the Sequel' amongst my friends."
This gives her a reason to give me a nice, full, over-exaggerated laugh. "That's definitely one way to put it!"
"Alright, well, I have to get to class. Sorry I couldn't help. Nice talking to you," I say. I nod my head once and begin to step away. My excuse to flee is a lie, but three more minutes of conversation with this woman was going to drive me up the freaking wall. And it's not like we had any important business left to attend to. It's just an easy excuse.
"Thanks! Have a good afternoon!" she gives me a wave as I walk away.
As I get to the edge of the square, I pause and turn back around. Thinking about the remark I made about Vietnam made me realize exactly how much this demonstration really is like one of the old "sit-in's" from the 60's and 70's. I think about how much my mom would get a kick out of it, so I pull my phone out to take a picture to send to her.
Putting the shot in frame, I notice a man a few feet in front of me also watching the rally. I begin to step off to the side to get him out of the frame when some electrical impulse travels through my brain, signaling something peculiar to me. Not only is he wearing a long, khaki overcoat and black gloves, but he's holding an umbrella in his right hand. I look up at the completely cloudless sky and wrinkle my eyebrows. I finish taking the picture and drop my phone back into my pocket. For a moment, I stand there and watch him.
New York, surprise surprise, is home to a shitload of crazy people. Hell, have you been reading these stories over the past few months? I mean, seriously. Anyway, some are obviously more interesting than others. So, generally, when I see someone that looks like they might be unhinged, I give it a minute; see if anything is about to happen. Most of the time, the world trudges on, unchanged. But every now and then, I find myself glad to have taken those three minutes out of my day and wait for an adventure.
A minute later and the man with the umbrella is still standing in the same spot; his extreme focus on the crowd in front of him. As I'm about to turn away, he slowly turns his head around in both directions, as though he's looking for someone. He turns his head far enough around to see me and, for a moment, he catches my eye. Nervously, I turn my head away from him and look over towards the seated crowd. The same man with the megaphone continues to speak to his audience. I'm still not listening to him.
A moment later, the man with the umbrella turns around and begins to walk toward me. He has those huge, bug-eyed sunglasses on and they make him look absolutely ridiculous. Not wanting to instigate Senor Cuckoo, I choose to ignore him and just stare over at the rally. I do this based on the supposition that, generally, crazy people are like ex-girlfriends; if you just ignore them, they tend to leave you alone.
But right now I'm not so lucky. Without saying a word, the man walks up to my right side, stops, and turns to face the rally as well. Standing side by side, I take in his height (roughly mine) and his build (slightly larger than mine) through my periphery vision. Not sure what to do, I choose to try and ignore him some more in the hopes that the results will soon turn in my favor.
"You a cop?" he asks him without turning to face me.
"Excuse me?" I ask and look at him. He doesn't look at me. So far, the results are not going in my favor
"Are you a cop?" he asks again, this time slightly louder and slower.
"How many cops do you know with huge holes in their ears and that wear DC shoes?" I ask him.
"Not giving a direct answer means you probably are."
"Okay, look, I'm not a cop. I promise. Just a student at NYU." I turn back to face the crowd.
"Not any kind of security or enforcement?"
"Nope, nothing. I swear. Just passing by and seeing what's happening."
"Why were you staring at me then?" he asks.
"Sorry?"
"You were looking at me before I walked over. Why?"
Paranoid schizophrenics, hoorah! I think back upon my decision to watch this man for a moment and wish I had decided differently. This is not the adventure I had in mind.
"Honestly?" I ask. It's a common reply of mine when the answer I'm about to give is somewhat odd and/or personal.
"No, lie to me," he says and continues to watch the demonstration. I chuckle before continuing.
"Well, cause unless there's something I don't know, you appear to be prepared for a thunderstorm on an essentially cloudless day. Just found it amusing is all."
"Huh," he says and looks down at his attire. "Never even thought about that. Knew I looked unusual, but didn't put it together like that until now." He looks back up toward the demonstration.
"Glad I could help," I say sarcastically.
"So what do you think about this sit-in?" he asks me out of nowhere.
"What?" is all I can think of to say.
"You're a student you said, right? And you appear to be observant, too. So I figured I'd ask you what you thought of all this, being a relatively intelligent person and all."
"Why thank you," I reply. "And truthfully I think it's kind of dumb. I mean, I agree with them about the war – being in that country is none of our goddamn business – but I just think the approach is stupid. Getting signatures to try and press Congress into action? Right. You'd be better off asking God for divine intervention."
The man with the umbrella laughs but still doesn't face me. And since I'd feel awkward looking at someone who's looking in another direction, I too, face the seated crowd. Our conversation persists in this odd manner.
"Pretty decent analysis," he tells me.
"Thanks," I say. "And you? What're your thoughts?"
"I don't think you want to hear my thoughts," he tells me.
"Oh, you'd be surprised. I'm studying to be a writer. I like hearing dissenting points of view, no matter how much I disagree. Helps to make my stories richer."
"That so? Well then, you sure?"
"Positive."
"Alright, you asked for it. But I wouldn't say I disagree with you, I think I just have a violently different perspective than you do."
"In what way?"
The man with the umbrella takes a deep breath and pauses. He puts his umbrella down on the ground and rests the handle against his leg. He starts to rub the palm of his right hand with his thumb. Finally, he proceeds.
"I don't think peace is a solution to violence," he says methodically.
"I'm afraid I don't follow."
He pauses again.
"Think of all the times you've seen violence in your life. How many of those conflicts were solved with hugs and kisses?"
"I assume we're not talking about girlfriends, right?"
He laughs before continuing. "Yeah, yeah, I know what you mean, but seriously. Violence is not cured by peaceful means. A bully doesn't stop being a bully until a force stronger than him puts him in his place. It doesn't necessarily have to be violent force, but it has to be threatening and it has to be able to back up its threats.
"I mean, take a boring example. What if, every night at dinner, your older brother stole your dessert so you could never have any? Finally, one day your sister says 'Hey, that's not nice. I demand you stop doing that in two weeks. I'm going to sit in front of your door every morning until you stop' What do you think is going to happen?"
"I would plan to continue losing my dessert." I say.
"As you should. But now what if your sister said 'You have two weeks to stop. After that, if I see you do it again, I'm going to tell all the cheerleaders at school that you're obsessed with gay porn and wear dresses when no one is looking.' Then what?"
"Then, considering the right circumstances, he may stop."
"Exactly. And if that doesn't work, maybe she'd threaten to poison him or something. Whatever. The point is that peaceful means doesn't stop someone from being a bully. A sit-in won't work. A petition won't work. Peace does not stop violence. And, further, violence does not beget violence. Violence actually cures violence."
"Wow, I never thought of it like…"
Before I finish my sentence, he continues. He's clearly emotionally charged at this point and is oblivious to my reply.
"How anyone, in this day and age, could think that peace can defeat greed and war is maddening. Here we stand, facing complete economic collapse, purely based on the fact that human greed has multiplied so violently that it alone is causing society to crumble. And how do these people want to solve it? With a letter in calligraphy and an RSVP card for the event. It's insanity. Absolute fucking delusional insanity."
"You got a point, man," I say and take a deep breath. "But whatcha gonna do?" I ask rhetorically.
"Make the peaceful violent," he says stoically.
"Excuse me?" I ask and turn to face him.
"Your sister. Threatening your brother in both scenarios. Same person. Only stronger the second time. What's different? The threat of actionable force. In short - you need to make the peaceful violent."
"And how does one go about doing that?" I ask, somewhat scared of the reply I might get.
"Oh," he says and pauses. "I have my ways."
"Look, if you're planning on blowing something up, can you tell me so I can get the fuck out of here and pretend I never met you?"
"Heh, don't worry. No bomb. Just me."
I pause for a moment and think. A thought pops into my head but I'm not sure if I should vocalize it or run for my life. My brain apparently makes the decision for me.
"So, if I understand you correctly, you're about to do something completely deplorable in order to make this mass of people turn from peace to violence."
"Essentially."
"And you're doing this because you actually want peace, right? You want an end to this war? And others, I presume."
"Oh God. In the worst way."
"But where does that leave you? A sinner fighting for virtue. A force of destruction that leads to a force of order. I mean, where do you see yourself in the grand scheme of things? Isn't that conflcting?"
A pause. A long one. His eyes remain invisible to me, but his mouth moves in a way that signifies his distress. Something I said set off a trigger. I hit a little too close to home.
"I'm not meant for this world," he finally reveals to me. "Nor the next. If there's a Hell, I'll probably burn in it. Forever. It's simply my lot. We don't all get to be Mother Theresa or Princess Diana. Some of us have to be Louis XVI or Rasputin. Some of us have to scorch the earth so badly that the people stand up and revolt and demand for something better. We have to ruin it to make it better.
"But there's no place for us here," he says and I notice the faint stream of a tear fall down over his cheek. "I'll die and be remembered as a monster. But no one will ever realize that I was a monster so that they could be happier. That I burned the world for them and for their children."
He pauses for a half second as he takes a breath and clears his runny nose.
"Now, if you'll excuse me," he continues, "I have to go make the world a better place."
Without saying another word, the man picks up his umbrella and starts walking around the crowd in a large arch around the crowd and toward the raised area where the man with the megaphone is. His stride is long and powerful. He always looks forward and never once strays his eyes to the sights around him. About twenty feet from the rally leader, he presses a button on the handle of the umbrella and it extends outward. It doesn't unfold, however, and only elongates. The strap is still wrapped around the end preventing a complete release.
But it's then I realize how odd he's holding this umbrella. Like it's too heavy to be held upright. Like it's something else entirely.
Then, my breath stops and my chest collapses.
I watch, not breathing, as the man raises the umbrella up over his shoulder like a baseball bat. Then, approaching the rally leader, he swings and connects. The end of the umbrella smashes into the back of his skull with a dull thud. The rally leader makes a face of surprise and agony before collapsing onto the ground. Before the crowd has a chance to realize what's going on, the man with the umbrella raises his weapon over his head and swings down as hard as he can. Screams erupt from the center of the crowd. The stranger drops the umbrella on the ground, turns, and runs off into the sunset.
No one is seated anymore. Half of the crowd is running away and the other half is running toward the center. I couldn't move if I wanted to. A police officer shows up and pushes his way to the front of the hysterical mass.
Minutes later, an ambulance shows up. Though I have no idea why. It's quite obvious from the way he's loaded into the truck that the rally leader is already dead. His head beaten in with, of all things, a loaded umbrella. The police have the weapon, but because of his gloves, no fingerprint ID will ever be made. His mission was successful.
Now normally, I never buy the newspaper. But the next morning, on my way to class, I make an exception. I pick up a copy of the New York Times and flip to the local section. There, I find the article I'm looking for. The headline reads "Peace Protester Murdered in Union Square". I skim the article until I found what I'm looking for – a quote from one of the assistant organizers.
"What happened today was a horrible tragedy. A kind and adored man was killed while organizing a rally devoted to peace. While we may never know the identity of the killer, his act has made our organization decide to increase its measures toward Congress. There are obviously forces which wish to stop us and so we must meet those forces with equal strength. That is why we are putting together a march on the UN building for six weeks from now where we plan on blocking the entrance and exit gates until our voices are heard. In sympathy for our former leader, we've already had ten thousand New Yorkers pledge their attendance on our website for this fateful demonstration against hate and war…"
So he was right. The peaceful slowly become violent. They're still far from a threat of great proportion, but they've taken the first step. They're on their way. Because of him, they might actually get the peace they ask for.
I smile.
But, somewhere in the city, I know there's a man sitting alone in his bedroom, looking at the same newspaper article.
And he's not smiling. He's crying.
(c) 2008 J.E. Tobal
I lol'd
" I once met a girl who, within 3 hours of introducing myself, was asking me to (a) let her satisfy me orally, (b) have anal intercourse with her, and (c) spread my cake icing all over her face. Oh, and not back at her place. In the bathroom of the bar. Swear. To. God." I was there for that... though not in the bathroom- I was entertaining the ugly one back on that cum-encrusted coach. good times.
Fantastic.